COMUNIST PARTY OF INDIA (MARXIST)
There are many political parties in India . By virtue of their policies they are called Rightist parties and Left parties . Communist Party of India (Marxist ) which is called as CPI (M ) in short is one of the left parties . Comrade Prakash Karat is the general secretary of it . There is a polit beaureu to take all the policy decisions of the party .But the Central committee of the party is the real head of that party .The Polit Beauraeu will lead the party during the time in between two Central Committee meetings .
It has a State committee in all the states of India .Comrade G. Ramakrishnan is the Secretary of Tamil Nadu State committee .
The party follows the doctrines of Karl Marx and Fredric Engles, who gave the world famous 'Das Capital' . They analysed how the mankind reach the present society .They found that the key factor of changing is the wealth . Who control the wealth and how it is distributed will decide the set up of the society . The govt ,military , laws ,justice ,police and all other parts of the society will stand by the controller of the wealth .
They said that this era of capitalism and presently it is going towards its end and socialism will bloom from the ruins of capitalism. It hopes not in heroes but in working people . They will fight till they get success taking the guidance of the Communist Party .
It vows to eradicate poverty and bring equality by bringing workers to power . Evils of the present society such as price rise,illiteracy, unemployment, diseases , caste ism etc. could be controlled and eradicated by applying Socialism as ruling policy . The evils of the present society are the results of Capitalism , Feudalism and Imperialism which are the governing policies of the present set up .
SO, CPI (M) appeals to the people of India Why not single colour?
We have seen tricolour(Cong) , double colour(BJP ,DMK); why not with single color that is RED . CPI (M) is ruling party in West Bengal above thirty years continuously , in Kerala for almost every alternate five years from 1967 and in Tripura for 25 years.
CPI(M) had the chances thrice ,to be Prime Minister of India .
It' s world famous leader Com. Jothi Basu who lead the party in West Bengal for three decades as Chief Minister was invited by all parties. But as the party is not a power monger one it refused the offers because it did not want to be depended on Congress Party for majority
Friday, November 26, 2010
Wednesday, November 24, 2010
கம்யூனிஸ்ட் கட்சியில் சிறந்த தலைவர்கள் உள்ளனர்.ஆனால் ஊடகங்கள் எல்லாமே அவர்களை எதிர்த்துப் பிரச்சாரம் செய்கின்றன .அவர்களின் சிறந்த தொண்டுகள் மறைக்கப்படுகின்றன.காரணம் அவை யெல்லாமே பெரும் கோடீஸ்வரர்களிடம் உள்ளவை.மக்கள் இந்த ஊடகங்களைத்தாண்டி உண்மைகளை உணரும் நிலையில் இல்லை. உலகமயம், தாராளமயம் வந்தபிறகு தொழிலாளர்கள் கூட தன் பெண்டு ,தன் பிள்ளை ,தன் சுற்றம் என மாறிவிட்டனர்.படித்தவர்களோ எப்படியாவது முன்னேறி தன் பிள்ளைகளை இஞ்சினியர்,மருத்துவர் என படிக்கவைத்து அமெரிக்கா அனுப்புவதே வாழ்நாள் கடமையாகக் கொண்டு வெறியாய் அலைகின்றனர்
On this day of resignation of Mr Raja ,the telecoms minister it is again worthy to know about communists.They rule over 33 yrs in west Bengal and Tripura and Kerala .They were /are not charged with corruption .Once Mr Nirupen Chakarabarthy ,10 yrs CM of Tiripura vacated his office and came to his party office to reside as he had no house or family to him .He brought only two suitcases as his total wealth .One had full of books and another had his dresses.News papers told that story with the caption ;WONDER;BUT TRUE.
It is a loss only to the people to ignore the communists.
We should understand West Bengal,Kerala and Tripura are the states in a capitalistic country that is India. States are helpless to change the fundamental policy of the country .They have limited powers .So it is not the communist governments .
In that limited power it had a great improvement in various aspects.Once WB is a dark state without current .Now it is giving electricity to others.It is the state which took a lot of land by implementing the land reforms and has distributed to poor.The total lands distributed in India WB has 40% lands .it is a great achievement .Many program mes such as unemployment allowance for youth ,old age pension for agri labours,33% seat allotment for ladies in local bodies , 8 hrs duty for police ,assn for police ,14 things of grocery in ration shops were implemented in that state as first in India .There is no religious or caste struggles in west bengal for 33 yrs.In Kolcutta the cost of rupee is higher than other cities which means that the cost of living is lower comparing o other big cities according to the central govt statistics .Now Kerala has implemented 50%for ladies in local bodies and this month Tripura is going to implement the same.
Please make a note that these achievements are attained with hardships as the central govt was always opposing the left ruled states.
For ruling 33yrs continuously is not an easy job without the support of the people .The problem is not with them but ours.We are fed with the wrong news items from the medias that are owned by millionaires.They always try to mislead the people according to their whims and fancies . Their policy is dead against communism which will stop their atrocities on labours.Naturally they poison people with anti communist propaganda .If you want to know about communists on any subject it should be taken from their organs ; but people always take it from capitalists media and create themselves wrong opinions .
Now all over Tamil nadu communists are struggling for he working class ,women ,minorities and dalits .Com A .Soundarajan ,was arrested and put in jail for guiding the workers of Nokia ;the police put handcuff to him ,a great leader of workers,a candidate of north madras MP constitution as if he is a murderer .The govt serve the foreign company as a slave.We close our eyes not to see the sacrifice being done by the communists.Stand a while and give ears to communist meetings
Communists blindly support none or oppose none ;it may be India,China,Russia ,USA .It is not in the name ; but in policy.We people are fed through medias of opposite parties to communists.We do not hear or see what communists say on anything.You read Dinamalar,Dinamani or Sun tv etc as if they are neutral .But they are the mouth piece of millionaires .Would they give against themselves .We should at least read Theekathir.
One fine morning a gentleman came to cong party office and joined in it.The next day India's whole finance is at his hand ;yes ,he is the finance minister .How is it possible?In 'Anbe Sivam ' you should have noted a street play.In it a rope from first floor direct the activities of men who are on the road .Like this ex IMF officer became finance minister and then PM .Please connect these points and agreements with USA .It is simple politics.USA indirectly through money dictates terms and our govt is dancing to the tune.
Communists never against free schemes in Tamil Nadu.They always welcome these schemes.Actually all over our state it is struggling in the roads to implement correctly these schemes.It feels upto the time of basical change people should get temporary relief such as ration system,unemployment allowance etc
In west bengal maximum of land distribution attained .so the next stage is industrialization to give employment to youth .The educational growth and buying capacity of the people had increased through land reforms.So it is planning to bring some factories .Central govt and Trinamul are against because if the plan of industrialization then the communists could not be defeated.So with the help of CIA ,maoists and all reactionary forces joining hands and spread false information. It is happening in Singur .
In Nandigram you will wonder if you know that a single cent of land was taken .Actually it was a central plan .The state govt was discussing it.As there was opposition it declared that the plan was dropped.But all forces except left joined and cried in high pitch and hurled bombs on police and killed constables and public who supported left.
Communists are not against FDR ;but the conditions coming with it are dangerous in nature.If they give commission other govts accept all the conditions they want (Bopal Tragedy Anderson was taken in a private plane with the escort of Collector and DSP to Delhi and he escaped to USA)But in Bengal it is discussed so that it can not violate the rules of land .(SEE what happening in Nokia )
Left may be defeated in coming election as there is only one policy among other parties that is NO to left.Cong and BJP ,Muslim League , maoists ,trinamul are joining hands together .If left join with BJP it can win cong in parliament election.But it will never happen as left are not opportunistic.Reg electricity I saw it from West Bengal official announcement in an advt .I will search for more evidence
Thank you for raising these doubts that are always pointed at communists . Communism has no ready made answers to all issues in all countries .The basic Marxism is applied for solving to all problems according to the accurate situation of that soil .So through their long experience from 1949 China decided to develop its strength and the world had to end avoiding and isolating China as it is the biggest market in the world.So China also accepted the technology and investments with conditions.(Not like India yielding to IMF conditions)They,China, laid conditions to install factories in border districts and after fixed period it would be taken to the govt of china.That companies accepted for it will give them a gain as it is the biggest market.A small % of gain also a great relief to them economically.This helped China to improve China.
But abiding for IMF conditions we get loss of employment ,price rise etc.Finally we should understand that internationalists like Communuists would never say no to FDI but only to the laided conditions along with FDI that are against our welfare with our 300 yrs of experience of slavery to East India Company.
The next point is alliance .Please be patient and analyse open minded without prejudice .First of all we should realise that we are in a state which is a small part of a great nation India.It is ruled for 60 yrs by capitalists ,landlords and foreign companies.Political parties that represent these section Cong and BJP are major political parties ruling India.They are the main reasons for India's present situation as the central govt is the major power in finance,administration ,legal ,force ,geographical situation.Its domination is the main cause of peoples misery .
So communists decide that the central power is the main enemy to the people.Defeating them could not be done alone by communists .So they have to align with sections who wants to fight with these major enemies. Left are ruling three states and with these force DMK/AIADMK though a smaller force would help to defeat cong/BJP .People in Tamil Nadu think that CPM is a small party only by taking its TN strength .A deep political knowledge would accept we are at the time of election add DMK /ADMK to our help to fight with big enemy of the people at that election and to defend people from the worst policy/party .
Here emotional thinking would not help to the people .Our election method is not democratic as needed.Polling % is 50-60.other 40% avoid voting .In polled votes winner gets 30-40% . Naturally if we took the maximum the winner gets only 40 x 60 = 24 % voters in total votes .So a minimum share of votes also is needed to fulfill our stand that the biggest enemy of the people in this election should be defeated and peoples should be defended from the MOST danger.So we use these opportunistic forces like DMK/ADMK/PMK/TDP/ SP/JD(S) ,in simple all secular forces.We know that these parties are not good but to avoid the most dangerous party to capture power . It is unavoidable.
They more over feel that at the time of election only we should fight for the welfare of the people.When the govt decide to attack with a worst action say raising petrol price people should come to roads and should fight for their welfare .Then only that action could be driven to backwards.So election only is not the solution to evils of the people.
Communists know that these valid points would not be understood and they would think communists are for only two or three seats .But they are thinking wrongly yielding by the mis propaganda of the all medias .For this they should not be punished by the bad govt.So they go their way to defend people accepting bad name as sacrifice and in faith one day they will understand .
They should be understood in the context of the history that Com Jothi Basu was thrice offered with PM post and he declined.At the time of UPA I, left had 61 MP seats and if it is power monger it would have got Vice PM post and many cabinet posts as DMK and PMK got.(PMK got 4 MPs and got Anbumani as Health Minister ).So they count only the welfare of the people not just MP/MLA seats.
As we go in train the trees outside the windows are looked like that they are traveling in opposite direction .Likewise DMK/ADMK often changing sides .Communists stand still on opposing cong.Who decide to oppose cong come to communists .This is the true position.Communists never change ideological stands as these opportunistic parties .What can they do?
As I told earlier CPM never aligned with cong except at the period of UPA I period .At that time to avoid BJP, the most dangerous party ,in ruling for the consecutive period after 6yrs worst ruling.
Communists are not in alliance with AIADMK now.so there is no need to come out .It will only be decided at the time of election.You see in west bengal ,kerala and tripura they have alliance with other parties namely left front/left and democratic front on agreed principles /issues with others.But in other states they have only seat adjustments to avoid the split of votes in defeating main enemy and to have the right to fight with the govt if they come to rule on issues against people. In recent bi election too it supported admk in its own separate stage as DMK allied with cong .When JJ announced they would support cong if Raja made resigned ,as a tactical move , CPM openly opposed .
In last month too CPM leaders met Stalin to press for taking action on Siruthavoor .Two months back they passed a resolution in Chinglepet NILA MEETPU MANADU to take the lands in siruthavoor and distribute to dalits.This is their basic policy .They won't give up for petty election benefits.Sedhu samudram project also they still demanding.Recently too their youth wing DYFI went on a rally demanding that project.Why should they give up it ?
You are charging Communists are for only 2 mp and 8 mla s; in the next line you are charging they didn't accept power in central govt .Is this not contradictory.it proves that they are in the line of policy not for mp/mla/minister
posts.
They want to defeat BJP and cong .In kerala ,west bengal ,tripura states it can be done on their own strength .So they fight against both in these forces.But they have no strength in other states . So they choose to defeat most dangerous between these two and supported cong /UPA in centre . you should see if they did not do so the BJP can be called to form govt. It is only for the people , they supported without minister berths.
Without enough strength they can't get successfully stop the cong in their wrong doings against people.Do you want communists to be a partner to cong to attack people? They would never.
Yes you are correct.Here secularism is mistakenly understood .But not by communists.By the govts and others.Religion should be their personal to a man.if they come to govt they should be APART FROM ALL RELIGIONS.It is secularism .But here they JOIN WITH ALL RELIGIONS.This is misinterpretation of secularism.
Terrorism grow by the govt.Sacchar commision report says Muslims are below to dalits after 60 yrs of secular govts of socialistic democratic republic of India.They support Israel against the basic policy of India up to the period of Rajiv from Nehruji.Joining hands with USA which is also against cong's basic policy against Nehru,Indira.
Terrorists of Hindu and MUslims are to be condemned.Communists also condemn terrorism of majority and minority religions.But terrorists to be separated from religion.All hindus are not terrorists and all muslims are not terrorists.
So only a common minimum programme was formuulated between UPA I parties and it was supported by left parties.As you correctly mentioned it was supported to avoid BJP ruling. In our democracy (?) there is only chance to select a more dangerous party than most dangerous party.
As I earlier mentioned ,a small portion of votes too should not be wasted in fighting the forces that is against the people.Left is demanding propotionate representation to avoid this type of seat adjustment but the other parties not accepting this.So it is unavoidable in our election method.As you are saying if left avoids such method there would be more strength to cong .So the alliance.If you think it for one or two seats then why did thrice CPM rejected Prime minister post.And at the time of UPA I period many cabinet including deputy PM could be got.Why did it happen?People should proud to this on CPM if they understand properly.
Siruthavoor issue is raised by communists not by BJP or DMK and till now it is trying for it.It is pity that DMK is avoiding to take action on ADMK as they are both same having policy on lands for which you are charging CPM as it is in power.
Arunachal issue is an border issue which is scheduled to talk between two govts and it would be settled by international norms and China and India could be friends in near future.
Absal Guru is not in first in line of cases for hanging and it would be taken by seniority according to the law of our soil
Thank you for your non compromising discussion and searching for the truth tirelessly.
It is the support of left ,after the election .Not in alliance with cong nationally at that time of election in 2004 or at any time in history.The cong and its alliance that is UPA didn't got sufficient seats to majority.If UPA is not ready for rule then president would call BJP/NDA. What should left do in that situation.Allowing BJP? So it pressed for a common minimum programme between of the govt of UPA and if it is acceptable to left they will support.Cong framed CMP and then only left gave support for govt.You see that after election any govt should be formed .There is no other choice .In that period also only communists fought on wrong doings of UPA such as petrol price hike etc till Atomic agreement.
Communists are not sanyasis to oppose power.Actually they are ruling in three states .They do not believe cong on which support JothiBasu could be a PM.What happened in case of Chandrasekar.Cong toppled that govt on the charge that a policeman was drinking tea in front of Rajiv gandhis home saying that he is a spy.This stain would have fall on left .They won't allow to rule or implement left policies .The experience in West bengal had taught very much on cong as it was laying hurdles in that state always.Will that party allow left to rule India?
Regarding DMK/ADMK/TDP/JD (S)/SP/RJD/BJD LJS etc it is very simple all forces of secular must be brought to fight BJP and cong.Left is using what comes with them in this fight.DMK and ADMK changing their stand often.If DMK support cong ,DMK come to left.If ADMK support cong ,DMK come to left .And left is accepting in the fight with BJP and cong.Don't see in number of seats see the policy .When these two parties supported Cong and BJP, left stood individually.There is their firmness in policy.
Communists policy is not a wrong one.That policy is accepted by all.Our country's name is in constitution having 'socialistic'.cong policy was drawn in AVdi cong by Nehruji as 'Socialistic model'.DMK at the time of Anna ,They were saying DMK is the original Communist party ;Kalaignar was /is famous for his quotation 'if i don't find periyar or anna i would have in hands with P.Ramamurthy ,A.Nalla sivam/R Nallakannu. MGR was saying Annayism is the collection of communism,socialism,and capitalism.
Not capable to rule? No; but you can say that the strength is not enough .As the capitalistic force is stronger with money ,power,medias (except Theekathir which is run in very loss)and above the people without political knowledge is the main reason.But left will win one day .
On this day of resignation of Mr Raja ,the telecoms minister it is again worthy to know about communists.They rule over 33 yrs in west Bengal and Tripura and Kerala .They were /are not charged with corruption .Once Mr Nirupen Chakarabarthy ,10 yrs CM of Tiripura vacated his office and came to his party office to reside as he had no house or family to him .He brought only two suitcases as his total wealth .One had full of books and another had his dresses.News papers told that story with the caption ;WONDER;BUT TRUE.
It is a loss only to the people to ignore the communists.
We should understand West Bengal,Kerala and Tripura are the states in a capitalistic country that is India. States are helpless to change the fundamental policy of the country .They have limited powers .So it is not the communist governments .
In that limited power it had a great improvement in various aspects.Once WB is a dark state without current .Now it is giving electricity to others.It is the state which took a lot of land by implementing the land reforms and has distributed to poor.The total lands distributed in India WB has 40% lands .it is a great achievement .Many program mes such as unemployment allowance for youth ,old age pension for agri labours,33% seat allotment for ladies in local bodies , 8 hrs duty for police ,assn for police ,14 things of grocery in ration shops were implemented in that state as first in India .There is no religious or caste struggles in west bengal for 33 yrs.In Kolcutta the cost of rupee is higher than other cities which means that the cost of living is lower comparing o other big cities according to the central govt statistics .Now Kerala has implemented 50%for ladies in local bodies and this month Tripura is going to implement the same.
Please make a note that these achievements are attained with hardships as the central govt was always opposing the left ruled states.
For ruling 33yrs continuously is not an easy job without the support of the people .The problem is not with them but ours.We are fed with the wrong news items from the medias that are owned by millionaires.They always try to mislead the people according to their whims and fancies . Their policy is dead against communism which will stop their atrocities on labours.Naturally they poison people with anti communist propaganda .If you want to know about communists on any subject it should be taken from their organs ; but people always take it from capitalists media and create themselves wrong opinions .
Now all over Tamil nadu communists are struggling for he working class ,women ,minorities and dalits .Com A .Soundarajan ,was arrested and put in jail for guiding the workers of Nokia ;the police put handcuff to him ,a great leader of workers,a candidate of north madras MP constitution as if he is a murderer .The govt serve the foreign company as a slave.We close our eyes not to see the sacrifice being done by the communists.Stand a while and give ears to communist meetings
Communists blindly support none or oppose none ;it may be India,China,Russia ,USA .It is not in the name ; but in policy.We people are fed through medias of opposite parties to communists.We do not hear or see what communists say on anything.You read Dinamalar,Dinamani or Sun tv etc as if they are neutral .But they are the mouth piece of millionaires .Would they give against themselves .We should at least read Theekathir.
One fine morning a gentleman came to cong party office and joined in it.The next day India's whole finance is at his hand ;yes ,he is the finance minister .How is it possible?In 'Anbe Sivam ' you should have noted a street play.In it a rope from first floor direct the activities of men who are on the road .Like this ex IMF officer became finance minister and then PM .Please connect these points and agreements with USA .It is simple politics.USA indirectly through money dictates terms and our govt is dancing to the tune.
Communists never against free schemes in Tamil Nadu.They always welcome these schemes.Actually all over our state it is struggling in the roads to implement correctly these schemes.It feels upto the time of basical change people should get temporary relief such as ration system,unemployment allowance etc
In west bengal maximum of land distribution attained .so the next stage is industrialization to give employment to youth .The educational growth and buying capacity of the people had increased through land reforms.So it is planning to bring some factories .Central govt and Trinamul are against because if the plan of industrialization then the communists could not be defeated.So with the help of CIA ,maoists and all reactionary forces joining hands and spread false information. It is happening in Singur .
In Nandigram you will wonder if you know that a single cent of land was taken .Actually it was a central plan .The state govt was discussing it.As there was opposition it declared that the plan was dropped.But all forces except left joined and cried in high pitch and hurled bombs on police and killed constables and public who supported left.
Communists are not against FDR ;but the conditions coming with it are dangerous in nature.If they give commission other govts accept all the conditions they want (Bopal Tragedy Anderson was taken in a private plane with the escort of Collector and DSP to Delhi and he escaped to USA)But in Bengal it is discussed so that it can not violate the rules of land .(SEE what happening in Nokia )
Left may be defeated in coming election as there is only one policy among other parties that is NO to left.Cong and BJP ,Muslim League , maoists ,trinamul are joining hands together .If left join with BJP it can win cong in parliament election.But it will never happen as left are not opportunistic.Reg electricity I saw it from West Bengal official announcement in an advt .I will search for more evidence
Thank you for raising these doubts that are always pointed at communists . Communism has no ready made answers to all issues in all countries .The basic Marxism is applied for solving to all problems according to the accurate situation of that soil .So through their long experience from 1949 China decided to develop its strength and the world had to end avoiding and isolating China as it is the biggest market in the world.So China also accepted the technology and investments with conditions.(Not like India yielding to IMF conditions)They,China, laid conditions to install factories in border districts and after fixed period it would be taken to the govt of china.That companies accepted for it will give them a gain as it is the biggest market.A small % of gain also a great relief to them economically.This helped China to improve China.
But abiding for IMF conditions we get loss of employment ,price rise etc.Finally we should understand that internationalists like Communuists would never say no to FDI but only to the laided conditions along with FDI that are against our welfare with our 300 yrs of experience of slavery to East India Company.
The next point is alliance .Please be patient and analyse open minded without prejudice .First of all we should realise that we are in a state which is a small part of a great nation India.It is ruled for 60 yrs by capitalists ,landlords and foreign companies.Political parties that represent these section Cong and BJP are major political parties ruling India.They are the main reasons for India's present situation as the central govt is the major power in finance,administration ,legal ,force ,geographical situation.Its domination is the main cause of peoples misery .
So communists decide that the central power is the main enemy to the people.Defeating them could not be done alone by communists .So they have to align with sections who wants to fight with these major enemies. Left are ruling three states and with these force DMK/AIADMK though a smaller force would help to defeat cong/BJP .People in Tamil Nadu think that CPM is a small party only by taking its TN strength .A deep political knowledge would accept we are at the time of election add DMK /ADMK to our help to fight with big enemy of the people at that election and to defend people from the worst policy/party .
Here emotional thinking would not help to the people .Our election method is not democratic as needed.Polling % is 50-60.other 40% avoid voting .In polled votes winner gets 30-40% . Naturally if we took the maximum the winner gets only 40 x 60 = 24 % voters in total votes .So a minimum share of votes also is needed to fulfill our stand that the biggest enemy of the people in this election should be defeated and peoples should be defended from the MOST danger.So we use these opportunistic forces like DMK/ADMK/PMK/TDP/ SP/JD(S) ,in simple all secular forces.We know that these parties are not good but to avoid the most dangerous party to capture power . It is unavoidable.
They more over feel that at the time of election only we should fight for the welfare of the people.When the govt decide to attack with a worst action say raising petrol price people should come to roads and should fight for their welfare .Then only that action could be driven to backwards.So election only is not the solution to evils of the people.
Communists know that these valid points would not be understood and they would think communists are for only two or three seats .But they are thinking wrongly yielding by the mis propaganda of the all medias .For this they should not be punished by the bad govt.So they go their way to defend people accepting bad name as sacrifice and in faith one day they will understand .
They should be understood in the context of the history that Com Jothi Basu was thrice offered with PM post and he declined.At the time of UPA I, left had 61 MP seats and if it is power monger it would have got Vice PM post and many cabinet posts as DMK and PMK got.(PMK got 4 MPs and got Anbumani as Health Minister ).So they count only the welfare of the people not just MP/MLA seats.
As we go in train the trees outside the windows are looked like that they are traveling in opposite direction .Likewise DMK/ADMK often changing sides .Communists stand still on opposing cong.Who decide to oppose cong come to communists .This is the true position.Communists never change ideological stands as these opportunistic parties .What can they do?
As I told earlier CPM never aligned with cong except at the period of UPA I period .At that time to avoid BJP, the most dangerous party ,in ruling for the consecutive period after 6yrs worst ruling.
Communists are not in alliance with AIADMK now.so there is no need to come out .It will only be decided at the time of election.You see in west bengal ,kerala and tripura they have alliance with other parties namely left front/left and democratic front on agreed principles /issues with others.But in other states they have only seat adjustments to avoid the split of votes in defeating main enemy and to have the right to fight with the govt if they come to rule on issues against people. In recent bi election too it supported admk in its own separate stage as DMK allied with cong .When JJ announced they would support cong if Raja made resigned ,as a tactical move , CPM openly opposed .
In last month too CPM leaders met Stalin to press for taking action on Siruthavoor .Two months back they passed a resolution in Chinglepet NILA MEETPU MANADU to take the lands in siruthavoor and distribute to dalits.This is their basic policy .They won't give up for petty election benefits.Sedhu samudram project also they still demanding.Recently too their youth wing DYFI went on a rally demanding that project.Why should they give up it ?
You are charging Communists are for only 2 mp and 8 mla s; in the next line you are charging they didn't accept power in central govt .Is this not contradictory.it proves that they are in the line of policy not for mp/mla/minister
posts.
They want to defeat BJP and cong .In kerala ,west bengal ,tripura states it can be done on their own strength .So they fight against both in these forces.But they have no strength in other states . So they choose to defeat most dangerous between these two and supported cong /UPA in centre . you should see if they did not do so the BJP can be called to form govt. It is only for the people , they supported without minister berths.
Without enough strength they can't get successfully stop the cong in their wrong doings against people.Do you want communists to be a partner to cong to attack people? They would never.
Yes you are correct.Here secularism is mistakenly understood .But not by communists.By the govts and others.Religion should be their personal to a man.if they come to govt they should be APART FROM ALL RELIGIONS.It is secularism .But here they JOIN WITH ALL RELIGIONS.This is misinterpretation of secularism.
Terrorism grow by the govt.Sacchar commision report says Muslims are below to dalits after 60 yrs of secular govts of socialistic democratic republic of India.They support Israel against the basic policy of India up to the period of Rajiv from Nehruji.Joining hands with USA which is also against cong's basic policy against Nehru,Indira.
Terrorists of Hindu and MUslims are to be condemned.Communists also condemn terrorism of majority and minority religions.But terrorists to be separated from religion.All hindus are not terrorists and all muslims are not terrorists.
So only a common minimum programme was formuulated between UPA I parties and it was supported by left parties.As you correctly mentioned it was supported to avoid BJP ruling. In our democracy (?) there is only chance to select a more dangerous party than most dangerous party.
As I earlier mentioned ,a small portion of votes too should not be wasted in fighting the forces that is against the people.Left is demanding propotionate representation to avoid this type of seat adjustment but the other parties not accepting this.So it is unavoidable in our election method.As you are saying if left avoids such method there would be more strength to cong .So the alliance.If you think it for one or two seats then why did thrice CPM rejected Prime minister post.And at the time of UPA I period many cabinet including deputy PM could be got.Why did it happen?People should proud to this on CPM if they understand properly.
Siruthavoor issue is raised by communists not by BJP or DMK and till now it is trying for it.It is pity that DMK is avoiding to take action on ADMK as they are both same having policy on lands for which you are charging CPM as it is in power.
Arunachal issue is an border issue which is scheduled to talk between two govts and it would be settled by international norms and China and India could be friends in near future.
Absal Guru is not in first in line of cases for hanging and it would be taken by seniority according to the law of our soil
Thank you for your non compromising discussion and searching for the truth tirelessly.
It is the support of left ,after the election .Not in alliance with cong nationally at that time of election in 2004 or at any time in history.The cong and its alliance that is UPA didn't got sufficient seats to majority.If UPA is not ready for rule then president would call BJP/NDA. What should left do in that situation.Allowing BJP? So it pressed for a common minimum programme between of the govt of UPA and if it is acceptable to left they will support.Cong framed CMP and then only left gave support for govt.You see that after election any govt should be formed .There is no other choice .In that period also only communists fought on wrong doings of UPA such as petrol price hike etc till Atomic agreement.
Communists are not sanyasis to oppose power.Actually they are ruling in three states .They do not believe cong on which support JothiBasu could be a PM.What happened in case of Chandrasekar.Cong toppled that govt on the charge that a policeman was drinking tea in front of Rajiv gandhis home saying that he is a spy.This stain would have fall on left .They won't allow to rule or implement left policies .The experience in West bengal had taught very much on cong as it was laying hurdles in that state always.Will that party allow left to rule India?
Regarding DMK/ADMK/TDP/JD (S)/SP/RJD/BJD LJS etc it is very simple all forces of secular must be brought to fight BJP and cong.Left is using what comes with them in this fight.DMK and ADMK changing their stand often.If DMK support cong ,DMK come to left.If ADMK support cong ,DMK come to left .And left is accepting in the fight with BJP and cong.Don't see in number of seats see the policy .When these two parties supported Cong and BJP, left stood individually.There is their firmness in policy.
Communists policy is not a wrong one.That policy is accepted by all.Our country's name is in constitution having 'socialistic'.cong policy was drawn in AVdi cong by Nehruji as 'Socialistic model'.DMK at the time of Anna ,They were saying DMK is the original Communist party ;Kalaignar was /is famous for his quotation 'if i don't find periyar or anna i would have in hands with P.Ramamurthy ,A.Nalla sivam/R Nallakannu. MGR was saying Annayism is the collection of communism,socialism,and capitalism.
Not capable to rule? No; but you can say that the strength is not enough .As the capitalistic force is stronger with money ,power,medias (except Theekathir which is run in very loss)and above the people without political knowledge is the main reason.But left will win one day .
வான் திருடன்
பகல் திருடன் பார்த்துள்ளோம்
பகலையே திருடமுடியும்?
நாட்டிலே பல திருடருண்டு
நாட்டையே திருடுவாரா?
பேசித்திருடுவார் பலர்
பேச்சையே திருடுவாரெவர்?
வான் திருடி வான் புகழ்
பெற்றவர் வேறெவர்?
ராசாங்கத்தை எவரெவரோ திருடுவார்
ராசாவே திருடுவார்?
There are thieves who steal in night
Is there anyone to steal night?
'Day thief' we had heard
Heard a thief who steal Day?
There are a lot of thieves in nation
Is there anyone to steal nation?
Thieves steal by talking
will he steal talking?
Thief steal to sky level
Who stole sky ?
Numerous thieves in a kingdom
King himself will steal?
இரவையே திருடுபவன் உண்டா?இரவுத் திருடன் அறிவோம்
பகல் திருடன் பார்த்துள்ளோம்
பகலையே திருடமுடியும்?
நாட்டிலே பல திருடருண்டு
நாட்டையே திருடுவாரா?
பேசித்திருடுவார் பலர்
பேச்சையே திருடுவாரெவர்?
வான் திருடி வான் புகழ்
பெற்றவர் வேறெவர்?
ராசாங்கத்தை எவரெவரோ திருடுவார்
ராசாவே திருடுவார்?
There are thieves who steal in night
Is there anyone to steal night?
'Day thief' we had heard
Heard a thief who steal Day?
There are a lot of thieves in nation
Is there anyone to steal nation?
Thieves steal by talking
will he steal talking?
Thief steal to sky level
Who stole sky ?
Numerous thieves in a kingdom
King himself will steal?
Tuesday, November 23, 2010
Office going ladies and house wives are very much depressed as they have to cook for her family and guests. They look after their husbands and children and the whole family .In the name of tradition and culture they are tortured.To bring a solution to this " kitchen less home" movement should be started .
If we say so ,a loud cry would start asking the question, 'then how would we eat? '
That is the problem of both the genders of a family. Let them jointly think it over on it.. The society should take the response like schooling , health ,transport etc.We can start messes in hamlets ,wards etc. We can appoint the house wives there to do the work there and they would earn money .If the food is prepared hygienically and served cheaper with the subsidy aid of the government ; it will o.k. or not ?.All men, women and children would go the messes and would have our food there.Aah.. ! What a pleasant life we would get .
If we say so ,a loud cry would start asking the question, 'then how would we eat? '
That is the problem of both the genders of a family. Let them jointly think it over on it.. The society should take the response like schooling , health ,transport etc.We can start messes in hamlets ,wards etc. We can appoint the house wives there to do the work there and they would earn money .If the food is prepared hygienically and served cheaper with the subsidy aid of the government ; it will o.k. or not ?.All men, women and children would go the messes and would have our food there.Aah.. ! What a pleasant life we would get .
ஒவ்வொரு வீட்டிலும் ஒரு சமையலறை .ஒவ்வொரு வீட்டிலும் குறைந்தது இரு சமைக்கும்பெண்கள்.மனித வளத்தை எவ்வளவு வீணாக்குகிறோம் ? நம் வீடுகளைக்கட்டும்போதே இனி சமையலறை இல்லாமல் கட்ட வேண்டும். பின் எப்படி சாப்பிடுவது ? கட்டாயம் கேள்வி எழும். ஏன் வீட்டில் சாப்பிடுகிறோம் ? சுகாதாரமான , சுவையான , சிக்கனமான உணவுக்காகவே . இப்படிப்பட்ட உணவு உணவகத்தில் கிடைத்தால் ? அரசு அல்லது கூட்டுறவு முறையில் உணவகங்கள் நடத்தலாம். அரிசி ,மளிகை மற்ற பொருள்களுக்குக் கொடுக்கும் மானியத்தை இதற்குக் கொடுக்கலாம்.
நம் வீட்டுப் பெண்கள் உணவகங்களுக்கும் வேலைக்குப் போகலாம் .கூடுதல்
வருமானம் .உணவுக்கு இன்னும் கொஞ்சம் செலவு செய்ய முடியும் .குடும்பத்தோடு
உணவகம் சென்று உணவு அருந்தலாம் . கடுப்படிக்கும் கடுமையான பணியான
சமைத்தலிலிருந்து பெண்கள் விடுபடலாம் .பண்பாடு என்பதன் பேரால் நம் பெண்கள் படும் அவதிகளில் இருந்து பெரிதும் விடுபடலாம் .குழந்தைகளை இன்னும் செம்மையாக வளர்க்கலாம் .சண்டையில்லாமல் சந்தோஷமாக குடும்பம் நடத்தலாம்.அன்பு !அன்பே எங்கும் இருக்கும் .
இதுவெல்லாம் சாத்தியமா? ஏன் முடியாது? ஒரு செய்தி.இண்டியன் காஃபி போர்ட் மூடப்பட்டபோது வேலை யிழந்த தொழிலாளர்களுக்கு வாழ்வளிக்கும் வகையில் ,அப்போதைய பாராளுமன்ற எதிர்க்கட்சித் தலைவர் ஏ.கே. கோபாலன் ஆலோசனையின்பேரில் நேருஜி ஆணையிட்டு ஒரு உணவகம் ஆரம்பிக்கப்பட்டது. அதுதான் இன்றைய இந்தியன் காபி ஹவுஸ் .புதுவையைத் தலைமையிடமாகக் கொண்டு சென்னை உட்பட ஆறு கிளைகளைக்கொண்டு இன்றும் வெற்றிகரமாக இயங்கி வருகிறது.
எண்ணுவதெல்லாம் எய்துப எண்ணியர்
திண்ணியராகப் பெறின். -வள்ளுவர்
பெண்ணடிமை தீருமட்டும் பேசுந்திரு நாட்டில்
மண்ணடிமை தீருதல் முயற்கொம்பே -பாரதிதாசன்
நம் வீட்டுப் பெண்கள் உணவகங்களுக்கும் வேலைக்குப் போகலாம் .கூடுதல்
வருமானம் .உணவுக்கு இன்னும் கொஞ்சம் செலவு செய்ய முடியும் .குடும்பத்தோடு
உணவகம் சென்று உணவு அருந்தலாம் . கடுப்படிக்கும் கடுமையான பணியான
சமைத்தலிலிருந்து பெண்கள் விடுபடலாம் .பண்பாடு என்பதன் பேரால் நம் பெண்கள் படும் அவதிகளில் இருந்து பெரிதும் விடுபடலாம் .குழந்தைகளை இன்னும் செம்மையாக வளர்க்கலாம் .சண்டையில்லாமல் சந்தோஷமாக குடும்பம் நடத்தலாம்.அன்பு !அன்பே எங்கும் இருக்கும் .
இதுவெல்லாம் சாத்தியமா? ஏன் முடியாது? ஒரு செய்தி.இண்டியன் காஃபி போர்ட் மூடப்பட்டபோது வேலை யிழந்த தொழிலாளர்களுக்கு வாழ்வளிக்கும் வகையில் ,அப்போதைய பாராளுமன்ற எதிர்க்கட்சித் தலைவர் ஏ.கே. கோபாலன் ஆலோசனையின்பேரில் நேருஜி ஆணையிட்டு ஒரு உணவகம் ஆரம்பிக்கப்பட்டது. அதுதான் இன்றைய இந்தியன் காபி ஹவுஸ் .புதுவையைத் தலைமையிடமாகக் கொண்டு சென்னை உட்பட ஆறு கிளைகளைக்கொண்டு இன்றும் வெற்றிகரமாக இயங்கி வருகிறது.
எண்ணுவதெல்லாம் எய்துப எண்ணியர்
திண்ணியராகப் பெறின். -வள்ளுவர்
பெண்ணடிமை தீருமட்டும் பேசுந்திரு நாட்டில்
மண்ணடிமை தீருதல் முயற்கொம்பே -பாரதிதாசன்
Saturday, October 2, 2010
வரலாற்றை செல்லாக்காசாக்கிய தீர்ப்பு
தற்போதைய அரசியலுக்காக கடந்த காலத்தை மாற்றி அமைத்துவிட முடியாது
- டாக்டர் ரொமிலா தாப்பர்
நீதிமன்றத்தால் வழங்கப் பட்டுள்ள தீர்ப்பு அரசியல் ரீதி யானதாகும். பல ஆண்டுக ளுக்கு முன்பே அரசு எடுத்த முடிவைத்தான் இது பிரதிபலிக் கிறது. நிலம் யாருக்கு சொந்தமா னது மற்றும் தகர்க்கப்பட்ட மசூ தியின் இடத்தில் புதிய கோவி லைக் கட்டுவது ஆகிய இரண் டின் மீதுதான் இந்தத் தீர்ப்பு கவனம் செலுத்தி யுள்ளது. மத அடையாளங்களை தற்கால அரசியலோடு பொருத்திப் பார்க்கும் சிக்கல் உருவாகியுள் ளது. ஆனால் இது வரலாற்று ஆதாரத்தை அடிப்படையாகக் கொண்டதாகவும் சித்தரிக்கப் படுகிறது. இது இந்த வழக்கில் இணைக்கப்பட்டாலும், தீர்ப்பின் போது தள்ளிவைக்கப்பட்டுவிட்டது.
கடவுள்கள் பிறந்ததாகக் கரு தப்படும் குறிப்பிட்ட இடத்தில் அந்தக் கடவுளின் நினைவாகக் கோவில் எழுப்ப வேண்டும் என்று நீதிமன்றம் அறிவித்துள் ளது. இந்துக்களின் நம்பிக்கை அடிப்படையில் எழுந்த கோரிக் கையை ஏற்றே இதைத் தெரி வித்துள்ளது. எந்தவித ஆதார மும் அந்தக் கோரிக்கைக்கு இல்லாத நிலையில், சட்டத்தை நிலை நாட்டும் நீதிமன்றத் திடமிருந்து இத்தகைய தீர்ப்பை யாரும் எதிர்பார்க்கமாட்டார் கள். ராமரைக் கடவுளாக இந் துக்கள் வழி படுகிறார்கள். ஆனால், அவர் பிறந்த இடம், நிலத்திற்கான உரிமை மற்றும் இந்த இடத்தை கையகப்படுத் திக் கொள்ள பெரிய வரலாற்றுச் சின்னத்தைத் தகர்ப்பது ஆகிய வற்றிற்கு இந்த நம்பிக்கை உதவ முடியுமா?
மசூதியைக் கட்டுவதற்காக 12 ஆம் நூற்றாண்டில் அங்கி ருந்த கோவில் தகர்க்கப்பட்ட தாக தீர்ப்பு கூறுகிறது. இதனால் புதிய கோவில் கட்டுவதை நியாயப்படுத்தியுள்ளார்கள்.
தேசியத் தொல்பொருள் ஆய்வுக்கழகத்தின் அகழ்வா ராய்ச்சிகள் மற்றும் அதன் அறிக்கைகள் அப்படியே ஒப்புக் கொள்ளப்பட்டுள்ளன. இத்த னைக்கும் இந்த ஆய்வு மற்றும் அறிக்கைகள் மீது அகழ்வா ராய்ச்சியாளர்கள் மற்றும் வர லாற்றாய்வாளர்கள் ஆகியோர் ஏராளமான மறுப்புகளைத் தெரி வித்துள்ளனர். நிபுணத்துவம் தேவைப்படும் இந்த விஷயத் தில், அதிலும் பல நிபுணர்கள் கேள்விக் குறியாக்கிய ஆய்வ றிக்கையை, ஒருதரப்புக் கருத்தை அதுவும் அப்படியே ஏற்றுக் கொள்வது தீர்ப் பின் மீது நம்பகத்தன்மையை ஏற் படுத்த உதவவில்லை.
தான் ஒரு வரலாற் றாய்வாளர் இல்லை என்பதால் வரலாற்று ரீதியான அம்சத்தை அலசிப் பார்க்கவில்லை என்று ஒரு நீதிபதி கூறியுள்ளார். ஆனால் இந்த வழக்கில் தீர்ப்பு சொல்ல வரலாறு மற்றும் தொல் பொருள் ஆய்வு ஆகிய இரண் டும் அவசியம் (!) என்று தெரி வித்துள்ளார். இவர் இப்படிச் சொன்னாலும் வரலாற்று ரீதி யான கோரிக்கைகள் மற்றும் கடந்த ஆயிரம் ஆண் டுகளாக இருக்கும் வரலாற்றுக் கட்டிடங் கள்தான் சர்ச்சைக்குரியதாக உள்ளது.
500 ஆண்டுகளுக்கு முன் பாகக் கட்டப்பட்ட மசூதி, இத்த னைக்கும் நாட்டின் கலாச்சாரப் பாரம்பரியத்தின் ஒரு அங் கமாக இருந்த மசூதி, ஒரு அர சியல் தலைமையின் தூண்டுத லின்பேரில் தகர்த்தெறியப்பட் டது. இந்த ஒழுக்கங்கெட்ட அழிவுச்செயல் மற்றும் நமது பாரம்பரியத்திற்கு எதிரான குற்றம் கண்டிக்கப்பட வேண்டி யது என்று தீர்ப்பில் குறிப்பிடப் படவில்லை. கட்டப்படவிருக்கும் புதிய கோவிலின் கருவறை மசூதி இருந்த இடத்தில் இருக் கும். இருந்ததாகக் கருதப்படும் கோவில் தகர்க்கப்பட்டது கண் டனத்துக்குள்ளாகியுள்ளது. இது தான் புதிய கோவிலை நியா யப்படுத்துகிறது. ஆனால் மசூதி யைத் தகர்த்ததற்கு கண்டனம் எழவில்லை. வழக்கிற்குள் இந்த அம்சம் வராமல் வசதியாகத் தவிர்க்கப்பட்டுள்ளது.
தவறான முன்னுதாரணம்
ஒரு சமூகம் என்று கூறிக் கொண்டு, தங்கள் நம்பிக்கை யின் அடிப்படையில் இதுதான் கடவுள் பிறந்த இடம் என்று அறி விப்பு செய்யக்கூடிய முன்னுதார ணத்தை இந்தத் தீர்ப்பு ஏற்படுத் தியுள்ளது. இனி ஏராளமான அவதரித்த இடங்கள் என்ற பிரச்சனைகள் உருவாகலாம். வேண்டுமென்றே வரலாற்று ரீதி யான சின்னங்களை அழித்தது கண்டிக்கப்படவில்லை என் றால், மற்ற சின்னங்களை அழிப் பதை எப்படித் தடுக்க முடியும்? வழிபாட்டுத்தலங்களின் அந் தஸ்தை மாற்றுவதற்கு எதிரான 1993 ஆம் ஆண்டு மசோதா பலனளிக்கவில்லை என்பதை நாம் கடந்த சில ஆண்டுக ளாகவே பார்த்து வருகிறோம்.
வரலாற்றில் எது நடந்ததோ, அது நடந்துவிட்டது. அதை மாற்ற முடியாது. ஆனால் அதன் முழுமையான தன்மையி லிருந்து அதைப் புரிந்து கொள்ள முயற்சிக்கலாம். நம்பத் தகுந்த ஆதாரத்தை அடிப்ப டையாகக் கொண்டு நிகழ்வுக ளைப் பார்க்க முனையலாம். தற் போதைய அரசியலுக்காக கடந்த காலத்தை மாற்றி அமைத்துவிட முடியாது. வர லாற்றுக்குள்ள மரியாதையை இந்தத் தீர்ப்பு செல்லாக் காசாக்கி விட்டது. வரலாற்றின் இடத்தில் மத நம்பிக்கையை அமர்த்திவிட்டது. வெறும் நம் பிக்கையை அடிப்படையாகக் கொண்டதாக இல்லாமல், ஆதா ரங்களை அடிப்படையாகக் கொண்டே நாட்டின் சட்டம் இயங்கும் என்று நம்பும் போது தான் உண்மையான சமா தானம் வரும்.
(கட்டுரையாளர்: பண்டைக்கால இந்தியா குறித்த பிரபல வரலாற்றாய்வாளர்)
தமிழில் : ஹரி
தற்போதைய அரசியலுக்காக கடந்த காலத்தை மாற்றி அமைத்துவிட முடியாது
- டாக்டர் ரொமிலா தாப்பர்
நீதிமன்றத்தால் வழங்கப் பட்டுள்ள தீர்ப்பு அரசியல் ரீதி யானதாகும். பல ஆண்டுக ளுக்கு முன்பே அரசு எடுத்த முடிவைத்தான் இது பிரதிபலிக் கிறது. நிலம் யாருக்கு சொந்தமா னது மற்றும் தகர்க்கப்பட்ட மசூ தியின் இடத்தில் புதிய கோவி லைக் கட்டுவது ஆகிய இரண் டின் மீதுதான் இந்தத் தீர்ப்பு கவனம் செலுத்தி யுள்ளது. மத அடையாளங்களை தற்கால அரசியலோடு பொருத்திப் பார்க்கும் சிக்கல் உருவாகியுள் ளது. ஆனால் இது வரலாற்று ஆதாரத்தை அடிப்படையாகக் கொண்டதாகவும் சித்தரிக்கப் படுகிறது. இது இந்த வழக்கில் இணைக்கப்பட்டாலும், தீர்ப்பின் போது தள்ளிவைக்கப்பட்டுவிட்டது.
கடவுள்கள் பிறந்ததாகக் கரு தப்படும் குறிப்பிட்ட இடத்தில் அந்தக் கடவுளின் நினைவாகக் கோவில் எழுப்ப வேண்டும் என்று நீதிமன்றம் அறிவித்துள் ளது. இந்துக்களின் நம்பிக்கை அடிப்படையில் எழுந்த கோரிக் கையை ஏற்றே இதைத் தெரி வித்துள்ளது. எந்தவித ஆதார மும் அந்தக் கோரிக்கைக்கு இல்லாத நிலையில், சட்டத்தை நிலை நாட்டும் நீதிமன்றத் திடமிருந்து இத்தகைய தீர்ப்பை யாரும் எதிர்பார்க்கமாட்டார் கள். ராமரைக் கடவுளாக இந் துக்கள் வழி படுகிறார்கள். ஆனால், அவர் பிறந்த இடம், நிலத்திற்கான உரிமை மற்றும் இந்த இடத்தை கையகப்படுத் திக் கொள்ள பெரிய வரலாற்றுச் சின்னத்தைத் தகர்ப்பது ஆகிய வற்றிற்கு இந்த நம்பிக்கை உதவ முடியுமா?
மசூதியைக் கட்டுவதற்காக 12 ஆம் நூற்றாண்டில் அங்கி ருந்த கோவில் தகர்க்கப்பட்ட தாக தீர்ப்பு கூறுகிறது. இதனால் புதிய கோவில் கட்டுவதை நியாயப்படுத்தியுள்ளார்கள்.
தேசியத் தொல்பொருள் ஆய்வுக்கழகத்தின் அகழ்வா ராய்ச்சிகள் மற்றும் அதன் அறிக்கைகள் அப்படியே ஒப்புக் கொள்ளப்பட்டுள்ளன. இத்த னைக்கும் இந்த ஆய்வு மற்றும் அறிக்கைகள் மீது அகழ்வா ராய்ச்சியாளர்கள் மற்றும் வர லாற்றாய்வாளர்கள் ஆகியோர் ஏராளமான மறுப்புகளைத் தெரி வித்துள்ளனர். நிபுணத்துவம் தேவைப்படும் இந்த விஷயத் தில், அதிலும் பல நிபுணர்கள் கேள்விக் குறியாக்கிய ஆய்வ றிக்கையை, ஒருதரப்புக் கருத்தை அதுவும் அப்படியே ஏற்றுக் கொள்வது தீர்ப் பின் மீது நம்பகத்தன்மையை ஏற் படுத்த உதவவில்லை.
தான் ஒரு வரலாற் றாய்வாளர் இல்லை என்பதால் வரலாற்று ரீதியான அம்சத்தை அலசிப் பார்க்கவில்லை என்று ஒரு நீதிபதி கூறியுள்ளார். ஆனால் இந்த வழக்கில் தீர்ப்பு சொல்ல வரலாறு மற்றும் தொல் பொருள் ஆய்வு ஆகிய இரண் டும் அவசியம் (!) என்று தெரி வித்துள்ளார். இவர் இப்படிச் சொன்னாலும் வரலாற்று ரீதி யான கோரிக்கைகள் மற்றும் கடந்த ஆயிரம் ஆண் டுகளாக இருக்கும் வரலாற்றுக் கட்டிடங் கள்தான் சர்ச்சைக்குரியதாக உள்ளது.
500 ஆண்டுகளுக்கு முன் பாகக் கட்டப்பட்ட மசூதி, இத்த னைக்கும் நாட்டின் கலாச்சாரப் பாரம்பரியத்தின் ஒரு அங் கமாக இருந்த மசூதி, ஒரு அர சியல் தலைமையின் தூண்டுத லின்பேரில் தகர்த்தெறியப்பட் டது. இந்த ஒழுக்கங்கெட்ட அழிவுச்செயல் மற்றும் நமது பாரம்பரியத்திற்கு எதிரான குற்றம் கண்டிக்கப்பட வேண்டி யது என்று தீர்ப்பில் குறிப்பிடப் படவில்லை. கட்டப்படவிருக்கும் புதிய கோவிலின் கருவறை மசூதி இருந்த இடத்தில் இருக் கும். இருந்ததாகக் கருதப்படும் கோவில் தகர்க்கப்பட்டது கண் டனத்துக்குள்ளாகியுள்ளது. இது தான் புதிய கோவிலை நியா யப்படுத்துகிறது. ஆனால் மசூதி யைத் தகர்த்ததற்கு கண்டனம் எழவில்லை. வழக்கிற்குள் இந்த அம்சம் வராமல் வசதியாகத் தவிர்க்கப்பட்டுள்ளது.
தவறான முன்னுதாரணம்
ஒரு சமூகம் என்று கூறிக் கொண்டு, தங்கள் நம்பிக்கை யின் அடிப்படையில் இதுதான் கடவுள் பிறந்த இடம் என்று அறி விப்பு செய்யக்கூடிய முன்னுதார ணத்தை இந்தத் தீர்ப்பு ஏற்படுத் தியுள்ளது. இனி ஏராளமான அவதரித்த இடங்கள் என்ற பிரச்சனைகள் உருவாகலாம். வேண்டுமென்றே வரலாற்று ரீதி யான சின்னங்களை அழித்தது கண்டிக்கப்படவில்லை என் றால், மற்ற சின்னங்களை அழிப் பதை எப்படித் தடுக்க முடியும்? வழிபாட்டுத்தலங்களின் அந் தஸ்தை மாற்றுவதற்கு எதிரான 1993 ஆம் ஆண்டு மசோதா பலனளிக்கவில்லை என்பதை நாம் கடந்த சில ஆண்டுக ளாகவே பார்த்து வருகிறோம்.
வரலாற்றில் எது நடந்ததோ, அது நடந்துவிட்டது. அதை மாற்ற முடியாது. ஆனால் அதன் முழுமையான தன்மையி லிருந்து அதைப் புரிந்து கொள்ள முயற்சிக்கலாம். நம்பத் தகுந்த ஆதாரத்தை அடிப்ப டையாகக் கொண்டு நிகழ்வுக ளைப் பார்க்க முனையலாம். தற் போதைய அரசியலுக்காக கடந்த காலத்தை மாற்றி அமைத்துவிட முடியாது. வர லாற்றுக்குள்ள மரியாதையை இந்தத் தீர்ப்பு செல்லாக் காசாக்கி விட்டது. வரலாற்றின் இடத்தில் மத நம்பிக்கையை அமர்த்திவிட்டது. வெறும் நம் பிக்கையை அடிப்படையாகக் கொண்டதாக இல்லாமல், ஆதா ரங்களை அடிப்படையாகக் கொண்டே நாட்டின் சட்டம் இயங்கும் என்று நம்பும் போது தான் உண்மையான சமா தானம் வரும்.
(கட்டுரையாளர்: பண்டைக்கால இந்தியா குறித்த பிரபல வரலாற்றாய்வாளர்)
தமிழில் : ஹரி
Monday, September 20, 2010
WE CAN END UNEMPLOYMENT
Unemployment is a basic problem in a society . Idle minds make Satanic thinking like terrorism , caste ism ,fundamentalism ,racism ,rowdyism ,law and order problems etc. All of us think it can't be controlled or finished .
Reasonable thinking, questioning us why ? Let us find the reason for the unemployment and then we can find a solution.
Here prevails the illiteracy .So teachers are needed .Trained teachers are here in plenty without jobs .
Crores of people are in need of sugar .There is enough sugar in godowns .If needed people get needed sugar the godowns will be empty at once and to produce sugar there will need sugar factories . There will employment opportunity .
Thus if needed buy dresses there will be a need for factories and they will accommodate lakhs of workers .
Take chapels for instance .If barefoot of India wear chapels and shoes ,which will decrease diseases ,all the shoe marts will be emptied soon.We may extend this list to all the items we use in our life .
The point is money . The buying capacity of the people should be increased . Then we can employ the maximum workers in our factories ,fields ,schools offices and in service sectors etc.
Here comes the land reforms which we forget to implement properly.In sixty years we do not share the resources between us properly.Few hundreds of land lords are having 60 %-70 % of the lands while crores of toiling mass having only hands as their wealth .There is a Chinese proverb :"a man is given birth with not only a stomach but also with hands and brain . So if we utilise the tremendous human resource properly we can do wonder .
We can share the land and give it to the crores of agricultural labourers and some money they will work hard to get the gain for themselves .Till date they are working for others only . The harvest will yield them money to buy things they need to live a decent life . They could not even think this type of life .In due course their next generation will have works in factories ,in govt services .
All is correct .Who will give the lands to the people ? The people with the help of the government ,if the govt truly intend to minimise the unemployment problem .
This will only happen when the govt is of toilers .Let us all work for it and close the problem of Unemployment
Unemployment is a basic problem in a society . Idle minds make Satanic thinking like terrorism , caste ism ,fundamentalism ,racism ,rowdyism ,law and order problems etc. All of us think it can't be controlled or finished .
Reasonable thinking, questioning us why ? Let us find the reason for the unemployment and then we can find a solution.
Here prevails the illiteracy .So teachers are needed .Trained teachers are here in plenty without jobs .
Crores of people are in need of sugar .There is enough sugar in godowns .If needed people get needed sugar the godowns will be empty at once and to produce sugar there will need sugar factories . There will employment opportunity .
Thus if needed buy dresses there will be a need for factories and they will accommodate lakhs of workers .
Take chapels for instance .If barefoot of India wear chapels and shoes ,which will decrease diseases ,all the shoe marts will be emptied soon.We may extend this list to all the items we use in our life .
The point is money . The buying capacity of the people should be increased . Then we can employ the maximum workers in our factories ,fields ,schools offices and in service sectors etc.
Here comes the land reforms which we forget to implement properly.In sixty years we do not share the resources between us properly.Few hundreds of land lords are having 60 %-70 % of the lands while crores of toiling mass having only hands as their wealth .There is a Chinese proverb :"a man is given birth with not only a stomach but also with hands and brain . So if we utilise the tremendous human resource properly we can do wonder .
We can share the land and give it to the crores of agricultural labourers and some money they will work hard to get the gain for themselves .Till date they are working for others only . The harvest will yield them money to buy things they need to live a decent life . They could not even think this type of life .In due course their next generation will have works in factories ,in govt services .
All is correct .Who will give the lands to the people ? The people with the help of the government ,if the govt truly intend to minimise the unemployment problem .
This will only happen when the govt is of toilers .Let us all work for it and close the problem of Unemployment
Every point has its other side
Nowadays people are restless . They prejudge everything and act according to
their idea . At last the results get changed and they feel depressed .To avoid this we may listen to others while they oppose us . Every point has its other side . It may not seen by us for many reasons . While others try to bring it to our notice in the interest of us , our short sightedness will bring a wall between the real and our assumption . So, try to be objective and get the benefit of hearing others.
Nowadays people are restless . They prejudge everything and act according to
their idea . At last the results get changed and they feel depressed .To avoid this we may listen to others while they oppose us . Every point has its other side . It may not seen by us for many reasons . While others try to bring it to our notice in the interest of us , our short sightedness will bring a wall between the real and our assumption . So, try to be objective and get the benefit of hearing others.
corruption
When my father died I had to get a death certificate and legal heirs certificate from Tashildar. V.A.O. who is a friend to me , asked me Rs.400/-. I mocked at him that , "come and search in my house ; if there is my father you don't give certificate". He signed and gave it to me "You go and say the same to Tashildar and get your certificates". Then I went to R.I. nearly five days and Tashildar took twenty days .Believe it or not the dispatch clerk took two days to put the seal on it .Finally I counted and found that I had spent RS.550/- to get the needed certificates.If I had given to my V.A.O.friend Rs.400/- I would have got it in four days instead of one and half month time. This is the position of our country .
But I would say that corruption is the product of our system .When the system is changed it would gradually decrease ,diminish and dis appear.When would it change ? If we, the people , join hands to fight till the end, it will.
Till that time ,we can oppose the corruption at top level first . Finding faults with lower level may correct . But it is like crushing of mosquitoes and letting off crocodiles. And because of the top bosses corruption grow to the roots. So ,let us start with 2G, Chethan desai , CWG,IPL etc.
When my father died I had to get a death certificate and legal heirs certificate from Tashildar. V.A.O. who is a friend to me , asked me Rs.400/-. I mocked at him that , "come and search in my house ; if there is my father you don't give certificate". He signed and gave it to me "You go and say the same to Tashildar and get your certificates". Then I went to R.I. nearly five days and Tashildar took twenty days .Believe it or not the dispatch clerk took two days to put the seal on it .Finally I counted and found that I had spent RS.550/- to get the needed certificates.If I had given to my V.A.O.friend Rs.400/- I would have got it in four days instead of one and half month time. This is the position of our country .
But I would say that corruption is the product of our system .When the system is changed it would gradually decrease ,diminish and dis appear.When would it change ? If we, the people , join hands to fight till the end, it will.
Till that time ,we can oppose the corruption at top level first . Finding faults with lower level may correct . But it is like crushing of mosquitoes and letting off crocodiles. And because of the top bosses corruption grow to the roots. So ,let us start with 2G, Chethan desai , CWG,IPL etc.
Rumours
Rumour mongers spread false news . It is officially rejected by China and Pakistan that Chinese who came to Pak occupied Kashmir were to help in historical flood that Pakistan had ever seen . Humanitarian helps are used for sowing hatred by vested interests like U.S.A. who started to mention the news referred . Please hold in mind that this USA told the world that Iraq has atomic weapons ,even though U.N.O. rejected it , and started war against it.And history taught it to return back to their country with shame before the mankind.
Rumour mongers spread false news . It is officially rejected by China and Pakistan that Chinese who came to Pak occupied Kashmir were to help in historical flood that Pakistan had ever seen . Humanitarian helps are used for sowing hatred by vested interests like U.S.A. who started to mention the news referred . Please hold in mind that this USA told the world that Iraq has atomic weapons ,even though U.N.O. rejected it , and started war against it.And history taught it to return back to their country with shame before the mankind.
Kalaignar continuously attacking left parties particularly CPI(M) vehemently that Maoists are the weapons of CPIM .A.B.Barthan and Sitaram Yechury replied sharply but in a low voice .Yechury told that Kalaignar knows all thing but to support Mamtha as an alliance party at the central govt he says so.
Maoists or Naxalites from the beginning of it attacking CPIM and its policy .Hundreds of its cadres were killed upto emergency period and now at least 250 cpm men have been killed after the recent parliamentary election .Knowing this how can one say that Maoist are the tools of CPIM.
For sometime now,there are plenty of meetings to praise Mr. Karunanidhi .He is enjoying it .But in contrary CPIM is exposing continuously his govts anti
dalits stand,law and order problem ,corruption ,price rise and supporting all wrong doings of central govt .Govt employees and labours of Tamilnadu come to the roads to press their demands.These are irritating him and he feels that these exposure may cause defeat in the coming assembly election he get worried .
DMK is aligning with AIADMK .-If this is correct , then it is right that Maoists
are the tool of CPIM.
Maoists or Naxalites from the beginning of it attacking CPIM and its policy .Hundreds of its cadres were killed upto emergency period and now at least 250 cpm men have been killed after the recent parliamentary election .Knowing this how can one say that Maoist are the tools of CPIM.
For sometime now,there are plenty of meetings to praise Mr. Karunanidhi .He is enjoying it .But in contrary CPIM is exposing continuously his govts anti
dalits stand,law and order problem ,corruption ,price rise and supporting all wrong doings of central govt .Govt employees and labours of Tamilnadu come to the roads to press their demands.These are irritating him and he feels that these exposure may cause defeat in the coming assembly election he get worried .
DMK is aligning with AIADMK .-If this is correct , then it is right that Maoists
are the tool of CPIM.
Pranab,Are you correct?
It shocked when I read a news item in 'The Hindu',Chennai edition , that our Finance Minister had spoken that he found nothing wrong in the speech of the Railway Minister Mamtha Bannerjee . Mamtha had spoken that inquiry should be done on the encounter of Azad ,a key cadre of Maoists .
Our Prime Minister has more than one time told that the most internal danger is the terrorism of Maoists . As a cabinet minister it is her bounden duty to defend her government policy and her Prime Minister . Morally also , all would accept that murders of general public , CPIM cadres and police men by Maoists are unpardonable.
We can understand if activists of human rights raise questions about
Azad 's encounter. That every culprit should be booked under rules of law and
it has not happened in case of Azad.
ButMamtha who is a cabinet Minister asks for inquiry. we can come to a conclusion that Mamtha is in a position to use all the stones to bring down the Left Govt of West Bengal and after all it is only her alliance party ,the congress ,that did the encounter. And Mamtha was always known to her contradictory politics .
But ,what happened to this elder politician ,Mr.Pranab. ? It is the Andhra Pradesh Congress government that encountered Azad . As a congress leader he should oppose her.In parliament opposition parties made charges on Mamtha and cornered Manmohan that he should come open to declare his stand on Azad's encounter and Mamtha's speech.
So, there is no other idea to us to take Pranab ,a minister from west bengal has no other go to defend her as the election is nearing in their state. Though she is not interested in defending congress ,can this gentleman could be so with his own party?
It shocked when I read a news item in 'The Hindu',Chennai edition , that our Finance Minister had spoken that he found nothing wrong in the speech of the Railway Minister Mamtha Bannerjee . Mamtha had spoken that inquiry should be done on the encounter of Azad ,a key cadre of Maoists .
Our Prime Minister has more than one time told that the most internal danger is the terrorism of Maoists . As a cabinet minister it is her bounden duty to defend her government policy and her Prime Minister . Morally also , all would accept that murders of general public , CPIM cadres and police men by Maoists are unpardonable.
We can understand if activists of human rights raise questions about
Azad 's encounter. That every culprit should be booked under rules of law and
it has not happened in case of Azad.
ButMamtha who is a cabinet Minister asks for inquiry. we can come to a conclusion that Mamtha is in a position to use all the stones to bring down the Left Govt of West Bengal and after all it is only her alliance party ,the congress ,that did the encounter. And Mamtha was always known to her contradictory politics .
But ,what happened to this elder politician ,Mr.Pranab. ? It is the Andhra Pradesh Congress government that encountered Azad . As a congress leader he should oppose her.In parliament opposition parties made charges on Mamtha and cornered Manmohan that he should come open to declare his stand on Azad's encounter and Mamtha's speech.
So, there is no other idea to us to take Pranab ,a minister from west bengal has no other go to defend her as the election is nearing in their state. Though she is not interested in defending congress ,can this gentleman could be so with his own party?
| Kitchen less homes All houses are having a kitchen and all homes are having one or two women cooks . What a loss of human resource ! In the name of culture we torture our wives , sisters and mothers . Release their potential and make it a wealth to our family and world . 'Then how could we eat ? 'certainly you would ask. It is the problem of both the genders . we would jointly find solution . All the wards , council areas will have a mess . These ladies may get jobs in them . Hygienic ,tasteful and cheaper food we will get there . All men ,women and children would go there and take their food in all times. 'It is an Utopian idea',you may say.But if we try and jointly bring this to the politicians they will cry louder as a point in their election manifesto . (Captain will be the first ). Cheaper ? How? There comes the govt .It may directly or through Co-op. institutions can handle these messes . Here you think that crores and crores are spent as tax cuts to the bigwigs of our nation like Anil and Mukesh . Why can't the people of India be given food subsidy . After all they are the real (indirect taxes) tax payers. Thus we can change the torturous and boring work of cooking into a happy one ; In the families no quarrels will happen .Love ...Love..! any where in our surroundings love only will prevail . | |||||||||||
The boys who were driven by he teacher for not memorizing tables and could not catch the mathematics , are successfully calculating money in running buses as conductors and in shops as cashiers . The boy who was told to stop from school for continuously getting fail marks in science is busy with his vehicle's workshops as mechanic where 'that' teacher repairs his car . The politician who is attractively speaking in stage for more than two hours told during his speech that he was beaten by his Tamil teacher for wrong pronunciation and so he stopped his schooling . An unskilled worker working in Abudhabi wrote to his English teacher thanking him , for he had punished him for misspelling words ; so only he stopped his studies and reach there with his friend and he wonder that he do not know how he speaks English so fluently in a foreign country.
You can come across these cases frequently .These facts are shocking while they are collectively reviewing . They say that our syllabuses and curricula do not match our life needs . And more they say who fail the exams which we conduct in schools and colleges are not really judging the capacity of the individuals .They are more talented than these exams valuate
These grave break between the real life and knowledge one gets through books should be narrowed .
You see around us . Engineers draw the blue prints but it is mason and his helpers who build our houses. While current is strucked the mechanical engineer calls local electrician (Uneducated)to put fuse in order . The bike is repaired by an uneducated mechanic . Carpenter corrects the doors and windows . Coolies are laying the roads to ride vehicles for educated and brilliant people . cook in hotels and in marriages are uneducated (there may some exception) who plough the fields to give food for intellectuals who could not put a nail in their walls without the help of the carpenter? Weavers make cloth and tailors make dresses . Are they well educated ? We can go on like this which i don't want.
What then the educated men doing ? Reading papers , books , and talking or teaching or writing about these items ; Planning how to eat differently and enjoying life spending money they get through corruption ,bribery etc....
So let us have a new look on uneducated .
You can come across these cases frequently .These facts are shocking while they are collectively reviewing . They say that our syllabuses and curricula do not match our life needs . And more they say who fail the exams which we conduct in schools and colleges are not really judging the capacity of the individuals .They are more talented than these exams valuate
These grave break between the real life and knowledge one gets through books should be narrowed .
You see around us . Engineers draw the blue prints but it is mason and his helpers who build our houses. While current is strucked the mechanical engineer calls local electrician (Uneducated)to put fuse in order . The bike is repaired by an uneducated mechanic . Carpenter corrects the doors and windows . Coolies are laying the roads to ride vehicles for educated and brilliant people . cook in hotels and in marriages are uneducated (there may some exception) who plough the fields to give food for intellectuals who could not put a nail in their walls without the help of the carpenter? Weavers make cloth and tailors make dresses . Are they well educated ? We can go on like this which i don't want.
What then the educated men doing ? Reading papers , books , and talking or teaching or writing about these items ; Planning how to eat differently and enjoying life spending money they get through corruption ,bribery etc....
So let us have a new look on uneducated .
Saturday, September 18, 2010
பகை முடிப்போம்
சாலையைக் கழுவியதில்
சேலையைத் துவைக்கும்
நிலைமாறு வதெப்போது
பாலைத் தேடியழும்
பிள்ளைப் பேய்ப்பசியும்
நீங்குவ தெப்போது
கூழையே குடித்துதினம்
வாழ்வையேமுடிக்குமவர்
வாழ்வுமோர் வாழ்வோ
ஏழைபாழையவர்
பிறர்க்கே உழைத்துதினம்
நாளைக்கழித்தல் நன்றோ ?
சூளையில்வெந்திடும்
செங்கலாய்ஆலையில்
கழனியில் வேகின்றார்
நாளை நல்லதொரு
வேளைவருமென
தேவரை வணங்குகின்றார்
கூடியழுதுதினம்
கோயில்நாடிசுகம்
கண்டமாந்தருண்டோ ?
கோடிகோடியாயவர்
கூடிப்பகையறிந்து
முடித்தலே வழியன்றோ !
சாலையைக் கழுவியதில்
சேலையைத் துவைக்கும்
நிலைமாறு வதெப்போது
பாலைத் தேடியழும்
பிள்ளைப் பேய்ப்பசியும்
நீங்குவ தெப்போது
கூழையே குடித்துதினம்
வாழ்வையேமுடிக்குமவர்
வாழ்வுமோர் வாழ்வோ
ஏழைபாழையவர்
பிறர்க்கே உழைத்துதினம்
நாளைக்கழித்தல் நன்றோ ?
சூளையில்வெந்திடும்
செங்கலாய்ஆலையில்
கழனியில் வேகின்றார்
நாளை நல்லதொரு
வேளைவருமென
தேவரை வணங்குகின்றார்
கூடியழுதுதினம்
கோயில்நாடிசுகம்
கண்டமாந்தருண்டோ ?
கோடிகோடியாயவர்
கூடிப்பகையறிந்து
முடித்தலே வழியன்றோ !
இரந்தும் உயிர் வாழ்தல் வேண்டின் பரந்து
கெடுக உலகியற்றியான்
-ஒருவன் உண்ண உணவின்றி பிச்சையெடுத்துத்தான் உண்ணவேண்டியிருக்குமானால் ,இந்த உலகத்தையியற்றிய கடவுள் ஒழிக!.
தந்தை பெரியார் குரலாக உள்ளதே என எண்ண வேண்டாம் ;பெரியார் கடவுள் இல்லை என்றார் .ஆனால் , திருவள்ளுவர் கடவுள் இருக்கிறார் ; அவர் ஒழியவேண்டும் என்றார் . என்னே வள்ளுவரின் மனித நேயம் !
அதனால்தான் திருக்குறள் உலக இலக்கியமாகப் போற்றப்படுகிறது .
கெடுக உலகியற்றியான்
-ஒருவன் உண்ண உணவின்றி பிச்சையெடுத்துத்தான் உண்ணவேண்டியிருக்குமானால் ,இந்த உலகத்தையியற்றிய கடவுள் ஒழிக!.
தந்தை பெரியார் குரலாக உள்ளதே என எண்ண வேண்டாம் ;பெரியார் கடவுள் இல்லை என்றார் .ஆனால் , திருவள்ளுவர் கடவுள் இருக்கிறார் ; அவர் ஒழியவேண்டும் என்றார் . என்னே வள்ளுவரின் மனித நேயம் !
அதனால்தான் திருக்குறள் உலக இலக்கியமாகப் போற்றப்படுகிறது .
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)